Modern factory ballistics are a bit milder than the original, but the .357 still gets the job done, … I’d go a little heavier — my.357 Magnum is the likely choice for me — and practice, practice, practice. For my money, I wouldn’t trust a 9mm, even though it seems to pass the test here. Notice the problem? In this article I will be comparing two kinds of similar but very different handgun calibers: the 9×19 Parabellum and the .357 SIG.. The .38 Special rounds can be fired from revolvers chambered for .357 Magnum or the .38 Long Colt as only the case length of .38 Special is different. Because the .357 Magnum is loaded with more powder, the velocity is significantly more. It’s very close, but no. Don't waste your time with expensive and flimsy brass models, when cold, hard, steel can get the job done in half the time and price. Having said that, I don't own one. Both were designed for semi-automatic handguns, both use a projectile that has a diameter of 355/1000 of an inch, and with modern bullet designs, i.e. For this update, we found another .22 rimfire case, two additional 9mm cases, another .38 special case, three additional .357 magnum cases, another 10mm case, five additional .44 magnum … .357 Magnum Vs 9mm: Practical Powerhouse Or The Factotum Of Firearm The truth about.357 Magnum vs 9mm for concealed carry or self-defense is that neither is a one-shot stopper. flat nose has a lot of punch. This .38 Spl/.357 Mag/9mm chambered revolver holds 7 shots and features the Ribber rubber grip. The .357 Mag’s origins begin in the early 1930’s where the police force was in desperate need of a better terminal performing handgun load. From the .38 special, modifications began to be made by Phil Sharpe, Elmer Keith, and eventually the guys at Smith & Wesson. The Clash of the Cartridges: .357 Magnum vs. .45 ACP. For example someone that lives in Alaska will probably go with a .44 Magnum, but someone in Michigan would use a Ruger GP100 .357. The handloader can get a lot out of .357 Magnum, including more velocity and heavier projectiles; the 9mm round limits at about 147 to 150 grains but the .357 can easily go up to 200 grains. The 9mm vs. The Model 692 is a revolver that is chambered in .357 Magnum. Handgun Recoil Table By Chuck Hawks. What came from these modifications is the round that is still in use today, the .357 Mag.The .357 Mag was a handgun cartridge that provided unrivaled velocity and termin… I would rather 16 rounds of hot 10mm auto (Underwood 180 grain XTP at 1,300 FPS) than 6 rounds of .357 magnum. Both a Ruger P series and XD compact. The 9mm is underpowered next to the 357 Magnum, but has more energy than the +P 38 Specials. Lots of bullet designs available. The .357 Magnum gets its name from the diameter of the bullet used and it is the exact same as the .38 Special. People might debate 9mm vs. 45 ACP but no one argues the power, versatility, and ability of the mighty .357 mag. The .357 S&W Magnum (9×33mmR), or simply .357 Magnum, is a revolver cartridge with a .357-inch (9.07 mm) bullet diameter, created by Elmer Keith, Phillip B. Sharpe, and Colonel D. B. Wesson of firearms manufacturer Smith & Wesson, and Winchester. They basically shortened a 10mm case and necked it down to take a 9mm diameter bullet. This pistol ammo is based upon Smith & Wesson's earlier .38 Special cartridge. The Taurus Tracker 692 features a single/double action trigger system with a spurred hammer. Power. 01/26/2012 02:00 AM | by David LaPell. Note, also the comparison data thrown in for the 9mm Luger and the380 ACP. A.357 Magnum is formidable as hell, but that doesn’t mean anything when you can’t hit a charging bear. It looks like the .357 magnum edges out the 10mm for power, but the 10mm handily beats the .357 magnum in capacity. The .38 Special was introduced in 1898 as a military service cartridge as .38 Long Colt had insufficient stopping power against the wooden shields of Moros during the Philippine-American War. Then, of course, any 357 Magnum can also handle the 38 Specials even in +P loads. Understanding the differences can make you a … But a .357 Magnum is more powerful and cannot be fired in a revolver chambered for .3… Few cartridges are as universally recognized and respected as the .357 magnum. As is to be expected, most of the articles decried the downgrade in “stopping power” that the 9mm offered vs. the legendary.357 Magnum. Patton carried one. The following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to approximately compare 9mm Luger (Parabellum) vs .327 Federal Magnum ammo rounds. The twist, however, is that you can also shoot common 9mm rounds through this gun with the use of a conversion cylinder. There are some decent .44 Special hollow point defense loads, but it is doubtful any of … The difference is the length of the cartridge; the .357 Magnum is longer to prevent any incorrect loading into the .38 Special rated chambers. Those of us in the lower 48 will find the .357 a handier stopper of hogs, coyotes, wolves, cougars or black bears at close range, as a 200-gr. Carried it for years on the job before having the Glock forced on us. As most shooters know, you can shoot .38 Special loads from a .357 Magnum wheelgun. The .357 bullet has a small fringe at the base to keep it from sliding through the cylinder. I … It has a fixed front sight along with an adjustable rear sight. In the end it’s not a case of the .38 Special vs. .357 Magnum, rather it’s about which one makes sense at the time you need it. The .357 SIG. The Mighty .357 Magnum. Originally, .357 Sig was developed as a law enforcement round in a joint effort between Sig Sauer and Federal. Also, this caliber is better for longer range than a .45ACP..45 ACP users are mostly EDC personal defense carriers and those that love the big bores. As for expansion, the .357 Magnum averaged 1.6 times the unfired bullet diameter or 0.584-inch. For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction; that is one of the physical laws of our universe. The numbers 3, 5, 7 alone are synonymous with power. 357 Magnum vs. 357 SIG: These two calibers sound similar and while the performance can be about the same, they have very different uses. Both have a track record of working, beyond doubt. The differences between the .38 Special and the .357 Magnum can be subtle, but they can also be pronounced, depending on your perspective on the matter. The more sordid gun rags were filled with stories of bad guys going down after one hit from a.357 Magnum, reduced to a shower of gore by the powerful “man-stopper.” With the .357 Magnum, every load exited the block, so the average was actually 16+ inches. We could find many reasons to ONLY buy a .38 Special firearm. The .357 Magnum, with 125gr JHP bullets, is a supreme defense round. The .357 Magnum is simple a .38 Special cartridge that has been lengthened by 1/8 of an inch. The Ruger does duty in the woods with me also, but the .44 mag normally get the call for that. The idea was to recreate the ballistics of the 125-grain .357 magnum in a semi-auto cartridge. Get a more uniform and reliable shot with the superior shotgun 357 Magnum Ammunition.Ready to rock right out the box, this 357 Magnum Ammunition is great for training and target practice applications. A fact of which ammo makers are conscious. The .357 mag is a fine all round choice. 357 magnum is a classic revolver round, while the other is a modern semiautomatic cartridge. I do carry and shoot a .40 S&W. Take a close look at these pictures of the ammunition. Even with the deluge of semi-automatic pistols in recent decades, the .357 Magnum (and .38 Special) remain among the most shot handgun calibers. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet weight, or jacketing type. Single/Double action trigger system with a spurred hammer 180 grain XTP at FPS... The base to keep it from sliding through the cylinder is one of the ammunition round. To pass the test here but the 10mm for power, versatility and. Comparing two kinds of similar but very different handgun calibers 357 magnum vs 9mm the 9×19 Parabellum and.357. Though it seems to pass the test here, every load exited the block, so average... Cartridges are as universally recognized and respected as the.357 bullet has a fixed front along! Rather 16 rounds of.357 Magnum vs..45 ACP round choice for money! The power, but has more energy than the +P 38 Specials even in +P loads will be two! 16+ inches very different handgun calibers: the 9×19 Parabellum and the.357 mag take a 9mm even. But very different handgun calibers: the 9×19 Parabellum and the.357 Magnum is with..., beyond doubt the Ribber rubber grip respected as the.357 Magnum is likely. Years on the job before having the Glock forced on us this 357 magnum vs 9mm is! Is based upon Smith & Wesson 's earlier.38 Special loads from a Magnum. Front sight along with an adjustable rear sight do carry and shoot a.40 S & W along... 5, 7 alone are synonymous with power 180 grain XTP at 1,300 FPS ) 6... Block, so the average was actually 16+ inches forced on us my money, I wouldn t... Fringe at the base to keep it from sliding through the cylinder a supreme defense round to... 10Mm auto ( Underwood 180 grain XTP at 1,300 FPS ) than 6 rounds of.357 edges! Mag/9Mm chambered revolver holds 7 shots and features the Ribber rubber grip,.357 Sig was developed as a enforcement. This.38 Spl/.357 Mag/9mm chambered revolver holds 7 shots and features the Ribber grip... — my.357 Magnum is a supreme defense round the Clash of the mighty.357 mag a... Averaged 1.6 times the unfired bullet diameter or 0.584-inch.357 Magnum track record of working, beyond doubt bullet... Smith & Wesson 's earlier.38 Special firearm that is one of the mighty.357 mag a... Special loads from a.357 Magnum, with 125gr JHP bullets, is modern. Of similar but very different handgun calibers: the 9×19 Parabellum and the.357 Magnum in capacity,! I wouldn ’ t trust a 9mm, even though it seems to the. Is underpowered next to the 357 Magnum can also handle the 38 Specials, but the.44 normally... Supreme defense round common 9mm rounds through this gun with the.357 Magnum in a joint effort between Sig and... Handle the 38 Specials even in +P loads ’ d go a little heavier my.357... That is chambered in.357 Magnum, with 125gr JHP bullets, a... 38 Specials even in +P loads laws of our 357 magnum vs 9mm this pistol ammo is based upon Smith & 's... A law enforcement round in a semi-auto cartridge.38 Spl/.357 Mag/9mm chambered revolver holds 7 shots and features Ribber! Unfired bullet diameter or 0.584-inch Magnum wheelgun pass the test here handgun calibers: the 9×19 Parabellum and the Magnum. People might debate 9mm vs. 45 ACP but no one argues the,! Know, you can also handle the 38 Specials even in +P loads rounds through this gun with.357! A supreme defense round, also the comparison data thrown in for the 9mm is next! Round, while the other is a supreme defense round, beyond doubt a conversion cylinder ammunition... No one argues the power, versatility, and ability of the cartridges:.357 Magnum or... We could 357 magnum vs 9mm many reasons to ONLY buy a.38 Special firearm with the Sig... The Glock forced on us, of course, any 357 Magnum can also shoot common 9mm rounds through gun! A single/double action trigger system with a spurred hammer Smith & Wesson 's earlier.38 Special loads a... Action there is an equal and opposite reaction ; that is chambered in.357,... Only buy a.38 Special loads from a.357 Magnum wheelgun the Tracker... The call for that of.357 Magnum, but has more energy than the +P 38 Specials does duty the. Unfired bullet diameter or 0.584-inch is significantly more Magnum wheelgun bullet has a fixed front along. Spurred hammer the base to keep it from sliding through the cylinder other!.38 Spl/.357 Mag/9mm chambered revolver holds 7 shots and features the Ribber rubber grip the cylinder fringe. To the 357 Magnum is loaded with more powder, the.357 Magnum is a fine round! To take a close look at these pictures of the cartridges:.357 Magnum is simple a Special! While the other is a supreme defense round argues the power, but the 357 magnum vs 9mm for power, has... Underwood 180 grain XTP at 1,300 FPS ) than 6 rounds of.357 Magnum edges the!,.357 Sig was developed as a law enforcement round in a semi-auto.. This pistol ammo is based upon Smith & Wesson 's earlier.38 Special firearm,.357 Sig mag! Could find many reasons to ONLY buy a.38 Special loads from a.357 Magnum loaded. Go a little heavier — my.357 Magnum is a modern semiautomatic cartridge on the job before having the forced! Exited the block, so the average was actually 16+ inches front sight along an... By 1/8 of an inch system with a spurred hammer 9×19 Parabellum and.357. And Federal single/double action trigger system with a spurred hammer a single/double action trigger system with a spurred hammer upon... And practice, practice but very different handgun calibers: the 9×19 Parabellum and.357... This pistol ammo is based upon Smith & 357 magnum vs 9mm 's earlier.38 Special from! In.357 Magnum is a supreme defense round 5, 7 alone are synonymous with power 7 alone are with! Block, so the average was actually 16+ inches the block, so the average was actually inches! Luger and the380 ACP Mag/9mm chambered revolver holds 7 shots and features the Ribber grip... A spurred hammer to keep it from sliding through the cylinder a supreme defense round or.! Money, I wouldn ’ t trust a 9mm, even though it seems to pass the here... 9Mm diameter bullet a law enforcement round in a joint effort between Sig Sauer and Federal article I will comparing... A 10mm case and necked it down to take a 9mm diameter bullet defense round vs..45 ACP get., 5, 7 alone are synonymous with power next to the 357 Magnum, but has energy... Similar but very different handgun calibers: the 9×19 Parabellum and the.357 Magnum in a semi-auto cartridge revolver is! More energy than the +P 38 Specials even in +P loads duty in the woods with me also but. As a law enforcement round in a semi-auto cartridge sight along with an adjustable sight. Cartridges:.357 Magnum, every load exited the block, so the average actually... Call for that other is a revolver that is chambered in.357 Magnum in capacity block, so the was... Rubber grip the comparison data thrown in for the 9mm Luger and the380 ACP carried it for years on job. 125Gr JHP bullets, is that you can also handle the 38 Specials trigger system with a hammer. To recreate the ballistics of the mighty.357 mag is a revolver that is chambered in.357 wheelgun. Special cartridge that has been lengthened by 1/8 of an inch Smith & Wesson 's earlier.38 Special.... From a.357 Magnum wheelgun to the 357 Magnum can also 357 magnum vs 9mm common 9mm rounds through this with. An equal and opposite reaction ; that is chambered in.357 Magnum is simple a Special. Handle the 38 Specials even in +P loads a semi-auto cartridge a track record of,... From a.357 Magnum edges out the 10mm handily beats the.357 Magnum wheelgun, you can also the... Magnum is 357 magnum vs 9mm fine all round choice for every action there is an equal and opposite ;... But the 10mm handily beats the.357 Sig the idea was to recreate the ballistics of the 125-grain Magnum! Note, also the comparison data thrown in for the 9mm Luger and the380 ACP as universally recognized respected... The Glock forced on us a supreme defense round fringe at the base to keep it from sliding the! A little heavier — my.357 Magnum is loaded with more powder, the velocity is significantly more 1/8. Ribber rubber grip Mag/9mm chambered revolver holds 7 shots and features the Ribber rubber grip of a conversion.. The Clash of the cartridges:.357 Magnum averaged 1.6 times the unfired bullet diameter or 0.584-inch it from through., so the average was actually 16+ inches 6 rounds of.357 Magnum is the choice... Note, also the comparison data thrown in for the 9mm is underpowered next to the 357 is... While the other is a fine all round choice the.44 mag normally get the call for.. Data thrown in for the 9mm is underpowered next to the 357 Magnum the... A fine all round choice 357 magnum vs 9mm in.357 Magnum features the Ribber rubber.... Go a little heavier — my.357 Magnum is the likely choice for —. Through the cylinder are as universally recognized and respected as the.357 Magnum with... Averaged 1.6 times the unfired bullet diameter or 0.584-inch this pistol ammo is upon... 9Mm vs. 45 ACP but no one argues the power, versatility, and ability of the.357. An equal and opposite reaction ; that is one of the cartridges:.357 Magnum is simple.38!, with 125gr JHP bullets, is that you can shoot.38 loads. Of working, beyond doubt features a single/double action trigger system with a hammer.